Rachel Haden, Tony Maxwell, and Anna Waronker, better known as L.A.-based band That Dog, are presumably still hard at work on a new album, their first in 19 years. At one of the band’s reunion shows in Chicago, The A.V. Club asked That Dog to play Punk Or Not Punk, in which bands rate random things on an arbitrary, dichotomic scale. In the video above, the band rates skinny jeans, nose rings, and No Doubt.